Do companies full of gossip really suck? A look at productivity and employee mental health
Here is what this post covers:
Introduction
Once upon a time, long ago, I worked full-time in the office on operations and maintenance for a large internal system.
Since the job was operations and maintenance, I was excited at the idea of sharing across teams the design patterns of the systems we each looked after, who built them and for what purpose, and what data formats the systems used to talk to each other. I thought that would give me a sense of the big picture.
But wherever I went, the conversation was all gossip, and I remember being a little disappointed.
So I looked into whether gossip actually raises a company’s productivity, and how it affects employees’ stress.
Productivity
Let me get this out of the way first: gossip is not the same as badmouthing. In research, gossip means “talking about someone who is not there,” and that includes neutral talk. In a study that recorded the conversations of 467 people, people gossiped for a whopping 52 minutes a day on average. But about three quarters of it was neither good nor bad, and only about 15% was negative.
That said, the cost is real. In a study of interrupted work, people who were interrupted worked faster to make up for lost time, and absorbed more stress for it. Someone pulling you into a chat while you are focused is exactly that kind of interruption.
So should you ban small talk? No. That backfires. In the case of a bank’s call center, giving each team the same break time so people could chat cut call handling time by more than 20% on the lower-performing teams.
Gossip also keeps cheaters in check. In an experiment with a game where players pool money, groups that could tell each other how members behaved kept cooperating longer. If you know slacking off will get around, you cannot get away with it.
But for the gossip lovers themselves, there is a catch. In a study that mapped relationships between employees, the employees who gossiped most were seen by peers as influential, but got lower performance ratings from their supervisors.
On top of that, in a meta-analysis of 52 studies, negative gossip was linked to lower engagement and performance not only for its targets but for the people who spread it and listened to it. The direction of cause and effect is still unclear, but the pattern is there: the people in the badmouthing circle tend to be the ones whose work is not going well.
The takeaway: the problem is not that gossip exists. It is what the gossip is about.
What employees actually think
Gossip can make the person sharing it feel better. In an experiment where participants watched someone behave selfishly, people felt bad, and that feeling eased once they could warn the person who was about to be taken advantage of. Gossip that protects others lowers the stress of the person sharing it, too.
Where good news gets passed around, employees are more satisfied. In a study of 1,267 employees, the more positive gossip people heard, the more satisfied they were with their jobs.
For the targets of badmouthing, though, the damage is serious. In a study of 403 supervisor and subordinate pairs, employees who felt they were being talked about lost their sense of being valued by the organization, and stopped helping their coworkers as much. The people being talked about quietly pull back.
The people talking and listening do not walk away clean either. In a study of 362 employees in Taiwan, employees who turned their frustration with the company into work gossip grew more cynical about it. The more you complain together, the more you end up hating the place. In a study of how listeners react to gossip, people who heard negative gossip became more afraid that they would be next.
Japan is no exception. In a 2014 survey by Nihon Hoki Joho, 43% named relationships as a source of stress at work, ahead of the work itself at 32%. Among relationship stresses, 26% named being the subject of rumors and badmouthing. People wear you down more than the job does.
So what should we do?
Getting rid of gossip entirely is impossible, and you do not need to. What should go is negative gossip. What should grow is talk that helps the work.
What companies can do
First, cut off the sources of anxiety. Research on rumors during organizational change finds that rumors spread most when the future is uncertain. The more a company holds back information, the more employees fill in the blanks themselves. Explain evaluation criteria and the reasons for reorganizations early and honestly.
Second, make it possible to raise problems openly. In Google’s Project Aristotle, psychological safety was the biggest factor separating high-performing teams. People talk behind your back because they cannot say it to your face.
Third, steer small talk toward the actual work. Spaces for sharing system design and how data moves between systems, like the ones I describe in the introduction, are exactly this. In a meta-analysis of 76 studies, teams whose members knew “who knows what” tended to perform better. Open design reviews to other teams. Have people talk about their systems at study sessions. In a company with no such spaces, of course the conversation drifts to gossip.
And the topics do not have to be the systems you work on. Databases, CI/CD, networking, backend, frontend, design, AI, game development, domain knowledge, side projects: any of it works. Talking about these things lets you look at your own system from many different angles.
What individuals can do
Negative gossip drags down how the people talking and listening are seen, and how they feel. Just do not join in.
If shutting it down on the spot is hard, hijack the topic: “By the way, where does that system get its data from again?” And if you need to report someone’s problematic behavior, take it to your manager or an official channel instead of spreading it around. That gets it fixed far faster.
Wrap-up
Do companies full of gossip really suck? Having gossip does not make a company suck. Small talk and sharing reputations support cooperation, and good news raises satisfaction. What sucks is a company where the talk is mostly badmouthing. Those are the workplaces where performance and morale tend to sink.
Looking back, what my old workplace lacked was not less gossip but a place to talk about the systems. Rather than banning gossip, give people a place to talk about the work itself. That is far better for both the company and the people in it.
References
- UC Riverside study busts myths about gossip (UC Riverside News)
- The Science Behind Why People Gossip—And When It Can Be a Good Thing (TIME)
- The Cost of Interrupted Work: More Speed and Stress - Mark, Gudith & Klocke (CHI 2008)
- The New Science of Building Great Teams - Alex Pentland (Harvard Business Review)
- Gossip and Ostracism Promote Cooperation in Groups - Feinberg, Willer & Schultz (Stanford Sociology)
- A social network analysis of positive and negative gossip in organizational life - Grosser, Lopez-Kidwell & Labianca (University of Kentucky)
- Spilling tea at the water cooler: A meta-analysis of the literature on workplace gossip - Wax, Rodriguez & Asencio (Organizational Psychology Review)
- The virtues of gossip: Reputational information sharing as prosocial behavior - Feinberg, Willer, Stellar & Keltner (Stanford Sociology)
- The relationship between positive workplace gossip and job satisfaction - Wang et al. (Frontiers in Psychology)
- Perceptions of Negative Workplace Gossip: A Self-Consistency Theory Framework - Wu, Birtch, Chiang & Zhang (Journal of Management)
- Gossip in the workplace and the implications for HR management - Kuo et al. (University of Salford)
- Receiving gossip about others promotes self-reflection and growth (University of Groningen)
- Nihon Hoki Joho’s survey on workplace stress (MONOist, in Japanese)
- A tale of two corporations: Managing uncertainty during organizational change - DiFonzo & Bordia (ANU Open Research)
- The five elements Google found for building effective teams (GIGAZINE, in Japanese)
- Transactive memory systems in context: A meta-analytic examination - Bachrach et al. (Journal of Applied Psychology)